• Welcome Home to Anchored by Hope
  • I Am Anchored By Hope: About Me
  • Shop Anchored by Hope
  • Unlock Unshakeable Hope – Download Free Christian Resources Today!
  • Contact
  • Categories
    • Faith
    • Motherhood
    • Mental Health
    • Beauty
    • DIY
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube

Anchored by Hope

Authentic + Biblical Encouragement

Categories: Faith, Motherhood

The Truth About Motherhood and the Mistaken Identity

motherhood

Becoming a Mom

Before my first son was born in 2016, I worked a full time job, a part time job, went to school online full time and still managed to date my husband, serve in church, work out every day, and have a social life.  

My schedule may have looked crazy to some people – sometimes it definitely felt overwhelming – but it was MY crazy.  And I loved it.  Crazy worked for me. It was a part of my identity.

When we found out we were expecting a baby, I had the utmost confidence in becoming a mom.  After all, I was already a self proclaimed master multi-tasker.  How hard could it be?

So, that was it.  I would stay home and Mike would be the provider. We knew it would require some faith financially, but we also knew God would provide.  And, He did.  

When Andy was three months old, Mike got his official acceptance into Local 73 Sheet Metal Workers.  He was a union man!  

A Little background

To put this into context, my family owned their own construction company when I was little.  I spent almost my entire youth in construction yards, at Truck shows, and learning how to run a crane. 

When Bongi Construction closed in the 90’s, my dad was still a union man, an operator for over 20 years for Local 150.  I was darn proud that my husband also became a union man; because I knew, first hand, how well we were taken care of, and I knew that Mike would now be able to offer our family the same support.

Almost seven years, lots of schooling, and an official Local 73 Journeyman card later, Mike is more than happy to be where he is.

I wish I could say the same.

Mistaken

I learned quite quickly that being a Stay at Home Mom was not as elementary as I had assumed.  It was the total opposite. 

Out of all the jobs I had, motherhood was, by far, the hardest.  

Never in my life was I so exhausted, confused, anxious, doubtful and drained.  But I also never experienced the joy or love I felt when I was cradling Andy in my arms, watching him explore every new scene and sensation, or hearing him coo and giggle. 

It seemed a fair trade, so I did my best to embrace this new normal and tell myself how lucky I was to have this opportunity to stay home, and that I was wrong – almost ashamedly so – to be unhappy.

A new opportunity

Andy was five months old when I was invited to an online party for Usborne Books & More.  An avid reader myself, I had stocked our house with books for my baby boy the moment the test read positive.  

The consultant had asked if I wanted to join, and truthfully, I did NOT.  I had my own salon at 23 and closing those doors was the hardest thing I ever had to do.  I didn’t know if I could handle failing at this. 

But I also had over $100 worth of books in my cart that Mike was not going to approve of.  Financially, it made more sense to join for $50, and get 10 books plus the opportunity to earn some extra cash.

That was the best decision I almost never made.  My book business boomed – and quickly.  I had a team of over 20 girls, promoted after a month, earned hundreds of extra dollars, and almost $1000 in free books.

This was what I needed; this was something I could work at without actually being at work, goals I could strive for and accomplish and see.

Oops! I did it again.

Two years into my little book business and I  suddenly felt that same loss and confusion I had when Andy was an infant.  It shouldn’t have taken as long as it admittedly did for me to realize that these same feelings were arising after the birth of my daughter. I realized that it wasn’t just the hormones, it was full blown postpartum depression.

Postpartum hits every woman differently. 

For me, it causes a case of mistaken identity.  I doubt who I am and what I’m doing.  My worth becomes blurry and entangled in the lies of the world.

By social media standards, as a SAHM I should be able to have an impeccable home, Pinterest worthy meals, hair and makeup selfie ready at all times (ok, that one isn’t very hard for me – I learned how to get ready in under 5 minutes in beauty school), and kids that are beautifully chaotic. 

Beautiful disaster

Instead, I was spending my days catering to my customers instead of my kids, popping frozen meals in the oven, and yelling at my beautiful babies for needing me.  The business that brought me joy was now a burden.  My health was fleeting, my mental stability was wavering, and I refused to ask for help.

Rather than seek God and trust that I was good enough as a mom, I continued to seek other avenues to fill the gap that was growing larger.  I developed a desire to help others who want a more natural approach to health and wellness, I went back to my beauty roots and started educating and empowering women on makeup and skincare, and while I found success and joy in both these places, my soul somehow still felt lost. 

It was like I was living someone else’s life.  

Changing seasons

Last winter, my family and I anticipated the arrival of baby 3.  I thought I was rock steady mentally; I was in tune with my body and my mind, I was thriving spiritually as I was daily in the Word, and, come on – I had done this twice already!  Baby 3, I was sure, would be a postpartum breeze.

Wrong.

Maybe it was just the season we were in – covid, quarantine, loss of loved ones, change – but this little nugget who decided to join us a few weeks early on Christmas Eve, completely knocked me on my postpartum behind.

And once again, I felt so disconnected from myself.

This time, I knew I needed help.  I joined the BetterHelp app and was synced to an amazing therapist who aided me in dealing with past trauma I never shared with anyone else before. 

Better Help

With my therapist’s encouragement, I took a step back from my businesses, and I started writing more consistently. In addition to prompting me to write more, she also suggested I read this book, Uninvited by Lysa Terkeurst.

I cannot recommend this book enough – I think every single woman needs to read it. This woman’s words hit my heart in a way that only scripture had before.  Naturally, I googled her and stumbled upon a website called Compel Training.  The homepage literally read “Your writer’s soul has found its place.”

I think I stopped breathing.  It felt like the Holy Spirit whispered those words into the depths of who I was created to be.  

I joined when they opened registration and started writing during nap time, after bedtime, in the morning at 4 AM before anyone was awake, literally any chance I had.  With every push of the keyboard, I felt like I was finding myself again. 

Joy

I relived that same sense of joy I did when I was bustling my butt around like a crazy person everyday before I became a mom.  I experienced that same sense of joy from submitting a book proposal that I did when I became a Red Jacket.

And mostly, I finally began to feel like I was right where God wanted me all along, sharing His truth and glory and story of redemption.

Being a mom, and a wife, and a daughter of Christ is proving to be the best full time job I could have ever imagined – once I learned to let it be enough (something I am still learning), and let it be my full time ministry.  

But God has also equipped us with gifts of the Spirit, and it’s only when our will is aligned with his that we can be fully immersed in true joy.  Compel has given that to me; a community of believers who seek to share the love of Christ by sharing our unique and predestined stories.

New mercies come in the morning

I never saw myself where I am; sitting at my kitchen table, kids napping, writing next to the big picture window, contemplating motherhood and the mistaken identity so many moms experience. 

It’s not easy to admit defeat, or let go of an image we created for ourselves.  I still see my fellow book bosses and wonder if I made the right choice letting go. I now share on the blog about our naturally well journey, motherhood, and my faith.  

I no longer feel like I’m walking in someone else’s shoes, but instead, feel like I am running my own race, staying contentedly in my own lane.

So, to all my fellow moms who may feel lost or like they’re living a mistaken identity themselves; know that you are loved beyond all measure.  Know that God is faithful, His word is true, and know that His grace is sufficient for you.  There is no shame in seeking counseling, asking for help, or trying to find a community besides the one consisting of little humans you birthed.  

Make no mistake, Mama, our ultimate identity is anchored in the Hope of Christ.  When you start to feel lost, I encourage you to remember that there is a Shepherd calling you by name. 

All we need to do is slow down and listen.


I hope this was encouraging for you! I would love for you to be apart of my email community! You can join HERE for weekly encouragement and more!

Want more Motherhood Mondays? Check out other posts from this series HERE!

If you found value in this, the greatest thanks I could get is a like or share!! I appreciate you being here!

Loading

Sharing is Caring:

  • More
  • Post
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading...

You may also like

About Nicole

Anchored by Hope is a lifestyle blog founded by Nicole domitro in 2017 to encourage, empower, and educate women on their journey of faith, motherhood, and mental health. Nicole is a wife and mom of three. After struggling with postpartum depression and anxiety, she started Anchored by Hope as a way to open up about her own struggles and help other women who might be going through the same thing. The blog aims to provide hope and encouragement for women of all ages and walks of life.

Meet Nicole

Meet Nicole

Hi, I’m Nicole, and Anchored by Hope is my story of transformation and grace. Before giving my life to Jesus at 24, I lived a life far from where I am today—a mom, homemaker, and beauty artist Anchored by Hope. With a background in Biblical Studies and a passion for helping women find beauty—both inside and out—I’m here to share how God’s Word can transform our everyday lives. Join me as I explore the messy, beautiful, and faith-filled journey of motherhood, homemaking, and living out God’s grace.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Search the Blog

Pinterest

PMDD And Christian Motherhood: How To Navigate Hormonal Struggles And Faith

faithful homemaking cover

Faithful Homemaking: How to Find Purpose in the Calling

Instagram

My littlest guy accepted Jesus into his heart last My littlest guy accepted Jesus into his heart last night 🥹🙌🏽

I want to hold onto this moment forever so I’m sharing it here.

Last night, Simon in all his jolly joy was professing biblical truths that honestly some of us can’t even comprehend or acknowledge; Jesus is Gods son who died for us, Jesus and God are one with the Holy Spirit, Jesus died for our sins on the cross, Jesus loves us so much. 

We talked about how when we accept Jesus into our hearts, there is nothing that can ever separate us from God. I told him that one day, when he was ready, we could pray together and invite Jesus in.

He wanted to pray that instant.

So we did.

The beauty of it all is this: Simon did something that holds so many people back from an intimate and intentional relationship with our Savior—he freely and honestly admitted his need for a Savior. He acknowledged that even at 5, he is a sinner—that he falls short of the glory of God, just like all of us (Romans 3:23).

But he also understands this: that it is while we are still sinners that Christ died for us.

I’ll be honest—when I first gave my life to Jesus at 23, it was hard for me to understand how someone so young could truly grasp faith like this. But God, in His sweet and perfect sense of humor, gave me three little ones who would.

I pray that my children would continue to grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ, and that they would love the Lord their God with all their heart, mind, soul, and strength all the days of their lives.

If you’ve been waiting—feeling like you need to have it all figured out first—you don’t. Faith can begin in the simplest, most honest prayer.

And if you’ve walked with Jesus for years, I pray this encourages you to return to that childlike faith—the kind that simply believes, trusts, and receives His love.
As a 3rd grade teacher, I get asked all the time: As a 3rd grade teacher, I get asked all the time:

“What books should my child be reading?”

And honestly… the kids who are growing the most in reading right now aren’t always reading the “hardest” books — they’re the ones who actually enjoy what they’re reading.

So I wanted to share a few things my students genuinely love right now:

📚 Read-aloud favorites
My class still gets SO excited for Nibbles (every time 😂) and they love longer stories too — we’ve read things like Cordelia and even The Wingfeather Saga, and they are completely locked in. Kids really do rise to the level of great stories when you read them together.

📚 Early chapter books
Nate the Great is still a favorite in my room — those confidence-building books matter so much at this age.

📚 For kids who think they “don’t like reading”
The Shine-a-Light books are constantly being picked up in my classroom. Something about the interactive element just clicks for those kids.

📚 For kids who love action/adventure
The I Survived series is HUGE right now. If your child loves those, they’re drawn to fast-paced, high-interest stories — which is such a great place to build from.

📚 Fun nonfiction lovers
My class is obsessed with question-and-answer books and 100 fact books — they love flipping, exploring, and learning random facts to share with each other.

Honestly, my classroom is kind of filled with these types of books (mostly thanks to generous teacher friends) because they’re the ones kids actually reach for.

If you ever feel stuck finding the right book for your child, I’m always happy to help 🤍

And if you want to browse, I did put a bunch of these favorites together in one place.
Feeling so grateful 🤍 Thank you for all the birthd Feeling so grateful 🤍 Thank you for all the birthday love—your time and words mean more than you know.

38 started off pretty sweet —literally 😆 Donuts and cannolis from Allegretis for breakfast, a protein latte in hand, a shutout win at the rink, and a mother–son skate with my boys.

Grateful for this life and the many blessings I’m so aware of.
Progress pictures 🥰🥰 I am so blessed 🥹. And not Progress pictures 🥰🥰 
I am so blessed 🥹.

And not in a “my life is perfect, nothing is wrong, look at me I’m blessed” kind of way. 

But in a “life is messy, I am a mess, and yet my rebel heart is constantly being lavished with love and encouragement through my God and His people” kind of way.

This whole summer has been one giant trust fall. I’m learning what it really means to surrender my expectations—to make my plans but ultimately let the Lord lead the way.

If you knew me before the age of 24, then reading these words probably feels nothing short of crazy 🤪. But friends—the goodness of God is real. It’s available to everyone if you’ll just believe, receive, and continue to follow Jesus.

Has this journey been easy? Absolutely not. But it has been filled with growth, faithfulness, and answered prayers beyond what I could have ever asked for or imagined.

So yes—I’m thrilled to keep sharing my classroom’s transformation, because it represents so much more than décor or bulletin boards. It’s a living picture of what the Lord can do when we simply trust Him.

✨P.S. I can hardly believe it, but my classroom wish list is almost completely fulfilled! 🥹 Just a few items remain, and I know the Lord will provide in His timing. If you feel led to help, it would mean the world to me and my students. 💛 
-> https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/2PA5A7D911SGY?ref_=wl_share
Prayer doesn’t have to be complicated. Some days Prayer doesn’t have to be complicated.

Some days my prayers are long, other days they’re just a whispered “help.” But one of my favorite tools for staying rooted in conversation with God is the P.R.A.Y. framework:

P — Praise
Begin by worshiping God for who He is.
💬 “Lord, You are faithful, good, and full of mercy.”

R — Repent
Confess where you’ve fallen short, and rest in His grace.
💬 “Forgive me for rushing ahead of You and for my impatience.”

A — Ask
Bring your needs (and the needs of others) to Him.
💬 “Give me wisdom for the decisions ahead and peace in my waiting.”

Y — Yield
Surrender your plans to Him and listen for His leading.
💬 “I release my agenda. Align my heart with Yours.”

You can use P.R.A.Y. in the morning, in a journal, while doing dishes, or before bed—it’s less about the “how” and more about the “Who.”

💌 I shared this full guide (plus a printable version you can tuck in your Bible) in my weekly email this week.
Not on the list yet? Join now so you never miss a resource or encouragement drop — the link is in my bio.

💬 Do you already have a prayer rhythm? Or is this a tool you’d use?
👩🏼‍🏫 TEACHER FRIENDS 🍎 I need you - especially if 👩🏼‍🏫 TEACHER FRIENDS 🍎

I need you - especially if you are teaching elementary ed (EVEN BETTER if it’s third grade 😆)! 

I have been nose deep in so many things the last couple weeks as I really prep for Fall! I would love to know a couple things if you’re willing to share;

1. Must have teacher supplies
2. Favorite ways to set up your room
3. Any and all resources for literally everything.
4. Things to add to an amazon wishlist
5. Best books - or ideas for how to create a perfect mini classroom library

I would be so grateful for any and all suggestions, recommendations, and encouragement!

Follow @iamanchoredbyhope

My littlest guy accepted Jesus into his heart last My littlest guy accepted Jesus into his heart last night 🥹🙌🏽

I want to hold onto this moment forever so I’m sharing it here.

Last night, Simon in all his jolly joy was professing biblical truths that honestly some of us can’t even comprehend or acknowledge; Jesus is Gods son who died for us, Jesus and God are one with the Holy Spirit, Jesus died for our sins on the cross, Jesus loves us so much. 

We talked about how when we accept Jesus into our hearts, there is nothing that can ever separate us from God. I told him that one day, when he was ready, we could pray together and invite Jesus in.

He wanted to pray that instant.

So we did.

The beauty of it all is this: Simon did something that holds so many people back from an intimate and intentional relationship with our Savior—he freely and honestly admitted his need for a Savior. He acknowledged that even at 5, he is a sinner—that he falls short of the glory of God, just like all of us (Romans 3:23).

But he also understands this: that it is while we are still sinners that Christ died for us.

I’ll be honest—when I first gave my life to Jesus at 23, it was hard for me to understand how someone so young could truly grasp faith like this. But God, in His sweet and perfect sense of humor, gave me three little ones who would.

I pray that my children would continue to grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ, and that they would love the Lord their God with all their heart, mind, soul, and strength all the days of their lives.

If you’ve been waiting—feeling like you need to have it all figured out first—you don’t. Faith can begin in the simplest, most honest prayer.

And if you’ve walked with Jesus for years, I pray this encourages you to return to that childlike faith—the kind that simply believes, trusts, and receives His love.
As a 3rd grade teacher, I get asked all the time: As a 3rd grade teacher, I get asked all the time:

“What books should my child be reading?”

And honestly… the kids who are growing the most in reading right now aren’t always reading the “hardest” books — they’re the ones who actually enjoy what they’re reading.

So I wanted to share a few things my students genuinely love right now:

📚 Read-aloud favorites
My class still gets SO excited for Nibbles (every time 😂) and they love longer stories too — we’ve read things like Cordelia and even The Wingfeather Saga, and they are completely locked in. Kids really do rise to the level of great stories when you read them together.

📚 Early chapter books
Nate the Great is still a favorite in my room — those confidence-building books matter so much at this age.

📚 For kids who think they “don’t like reading”
The Shine-a-Light books are constantly being picked up in my classroom. Something about the interactive element just clicks for those kids.

📚 For kids who love action/adventure
The I Survived series is HUGE right now. If your child loves those, they’re drawn to fast-paced, high-interest stories — which is such a great place to build from.

📚 Fun nonfiction lovers
My class is obsessed with question-and-answer books and 100 fact books — they love flipping, exploring, and learning random facts to share with each other.

Honestly, my classroom is kind of filled with these types of books (mostly thanks to generous teacher friends) because they’re the ones kids actually reach for.

If you ever feel stuck finding the right book for your child, I’m always happy to help 🤍

And if you want to browse, I did put a bunch of these favorites together in one place.
Feeling so grateful 🤍 Thank you for all the birthd Feeling so grateful 🤍 Thank you for all the birthday love—your time and words mean more than you know.

38 started off pretty sweet —literally 😆 Donuts and cannolis from Allegretis for breakfast, a protein latte in hand, a shutout win at the rink, and a mother–son skate with my boys.

Grateful for this life and the many blessings I’m so aware of.
Progress pictures 🥰🥰 I am so blessed 🥹. And not Progress pictures 🥰🥰 
I am so blessed 🥹.

And not in a “my life is perfect, nothing is wrong, look at me I’m blessed” kind of way. 

But in a “life is messy, I am a mess, and yet my rebel heart is constantly being lavished with love and encouragement through my God and His people” kind of way.

This whole summer has been one giant trust fall. I’m learning what it really means to surrender my expectations—to make my plans but ultimately let the Lord lead the way.

If you knew me before the age of 24, then reading these words probably feels nothing short of crazy 🤪. But friends—the goodness of God is real. It’s available to everyone if you’ll just believe, receive, and continue to follow Jesus.

Has this journey been easy? Absolutely not. But it has been filled with growth, faithfulness, and answered prayers beyond what I could have ever asked for or imagined.

So yes—I’m thrilled to keep sharing my classroom’s transformation, because it represents so much more than décor or bulletin boards. It’s a living picture of what the Lord can do when we simply trust Him.

✨P.S. I can hardly believe it, but my classroom wish list is almost completely fulfilled! 🥹 Just a few items remain, and I know the Lord will provide in His timing. If you feel led to help, it would mean the world to me and my students. 💛 
-> https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/2PA5A7D911SGY?ref_=wl_share
Prayer doesn’t have to be complicated. Some days Prayer doesn’t have to be complicated.

Some days my prayers are long, other days they’re just a whispered “help.” But one of my favorite tools for staying rooted in conversation with God is the P.R.A.Y. framework:

P — Praise
Begin by worshiping God for who He is.
💬 “Lord, You are faithful, good, and full of mercy.”

R — Repent
Confess where you’ve fallen short, and rest in His grace.
💬 “Forgive me for rushing ahead of You and for my impatience.”

A — Ask
Bring your needs (and the needs of others) to Him.
💬 “Give me wisdom for the decisions ahead and peace in my waiting.”

Y — Yield
Surrender your plans to Him and listen for His leading.
💬 “I release my agenda. Align my heart with Yours.”

You can use P.R.A.Y. in the morning, in a journal, while doing dishes, or before bed—it’s less about the “how” and more about the “Who.”

💌 I shared this full guide (plus a printable version you can tuck in your Bible) in my weekly email this week.
Not on the list yet? Join now so you never miss a resource or encouragement drop — the link is in my bio.

💬 Do you already have a prayer rhythm? Or is this a tool you’d use?
👩🏼‍🏫 TEACHER FRIENDS 🍎 I need you - especially if 👩🏼‍🏫 TEACHER FRIENDS 🍎

I need you - especially if you are teaching elementary ed (EVEN BETTER if it’s third grade 😆)! 

I have been nose deep in so many things the last couple weeks as I really prep for Fall! I would love to know a couple things if you’re willing to share;

1. Must have teacher supplies
2. Favorite ways to set up your room
3. Any and all resources for literally everything.
4. Things to add to an amazon wishlist
5. Best books - or ideas for how to create a perfect mini classroom library

I would be so grateful for any and all suggestions, recommendations, and encouragement!

Copyright © 2026 · Theme by Blog Pixie

%d